Our Channels

publication date

Share:

ISER and institutions oppose the privatization of prisons

Bill 190/2019 has already been discussed in the ALERJ plenary
and should be voted on next week

The Institute of Religious Studies and more than 40 entities, institutions and movements sign a technical note opposing PL 190/2019, which proposes the privatization of prisons in Rio de Janeiro and was submitted for discussion in the plenary of the Legislative Assembly of the State of Rio de Janeiro Janeiro (ALERJ) last Wednesday (10). Representatives of civil society institutions and movements that signed the text were present at the session that discussed the project. The text of the note brings together arguments that demonstrate the presence of unconstitutionality, illegality and unconventionality in the matter, contrary to the State's attribution for the protection of prisoners.

The public-private partnership proposal presented in PL 190/2019 violates article 144 of the federal constitution, Law 11,079/2004, on public-private partnerships, and Law 13,190/2015, which amends the Criminal Executions Law. The responsibility for managing the penitentiary system belongs to the State and the attempt to privatize the units will not resolve the challenges and crisis that the Rio de Janeiro prison system is going through at the moment, and may even worsen the conditions of safety and dignity of prisoners and staff. of the system. Added to this is the violation of article 134, regarding the exclusive competence of the Public Defender's Office to provide legal assistance.

The proposal to allow the exploitation of labor by the concessionary company, under a forced labor regime, in violation of ILO Convention 029, is extremely serious. The illegal use of the labor of pre-trial and sentenced prisoners and the sale of products resulting from this exploitation would serve the economic interests of concessionary companies, to the detriment of the implementation of a public policy that promotes the dignity of prisoners, their resocialization and their insertion into the labor market. formal work.

The supposed justification presented in the PL regarding the deficit of places in the system must be problematized taking into account that 40% of the 52 thousand prisoners are provisional and have not yet been sentenced. Furthermore, the Federal Supreme Court has already recognized the need for extrication policies, in the judgment of ADPF 347, which determined the implementation of custody hearings throughout Brazil, with the aim of reducing the growing rate of incarceration in the country. . In Rio de Janeiro, this rate reached the mark of 301.9 thousand/100 thousand inhabitants, according to data from the National Penitentiary Department in 2016.

Privatizing the prison system and increasing the number of places, therefore, will worsen the incarceration curve, generating more violence in prisons. The State must make efforts to comply with the Criminal Executions Law and promote a public policy that invests in improvements in the conditions of the system, food for prisoners, physical and mental health care, and the working conditions of system employees.

Read the technical note in full:
Technical Note PL No. 190_2019